Gardner Pie Company - Cream Pies

What happens when you combine our tender, flaky crust with a smooth, creamy filling made from scratch? You get a home-cooked cream pie delicious enough to bear the Gardner name.

We’re now making cream pies in six
delectable flavors:

Banana
Butterscotch
Chocolate

Coconut Cream

Lemon
Peanut Butter

Banana Cream Pie
You’ll go bananas for this cream pie. That’s because we include a generous amount of real banana slices in every pie – the equivalent to one whole banana. A subtle and sweet vanilla pudding provides the perfect filling for this creamy and refreshing treat.

Butterscotch Cream Pie
You won’t find any artificial flavors or colors in our butterscotch cream pie. Whole milk and butter give this pie its silky smooth texture, while burnt sugar is used to develop its rich, authentic butterscotch flavor. The result is a rich and creamy pie with the distinctive taste of true butterscotch.

Chocolate Cream Pie
Chocolate lovers will delight in this cream pie, which uses both dark chocolate and cocoa powder for a rich, dense chocolate flavor. Whole milk and fresh butter create a pudding that is smooth, creamy – and guaranteed to satisfy that chocolate craving. Perfect anytime! Add your own whipped topping for a hand made appearance.

Coconut Cream Pie
This classic cream pie starts with a silky smooth pudding that is positively heavenly. Fresh, long-shred coconut gives it its distinctive, traditional flavor. There’s simply no substitute for the homemade goodness of this ever-popular cream pie.

Lemon Cream Pie
Fresh lemon juice and lemon zest give this pie its refreshing lemon flavor. The lemon filling is just as smooth, tart and delicious as our other cream pies. Billows of meringue will add the perfect finishing touch to this flavorful classic pie.

Peanut Butter Cream Pie
Peanut lovers can’t resist this simple, classic treat. Just like homemade, our peanut butter cream pie is made with real peanut butter. Smooth and creamy, it’s packed with peanut flavor. Make it even more special with your own whipped topping, shaved chocolate or chopped nuts.

The Gardner Pie Company, located in Akron, Ohio, has been family owned and operated since 1945. We offer a wide variety of quality pies for farm markets, in-store bakeries, retail bake shops and the food service industry.